top of page
Writer's pictureKlep Napier

[REVIEW]: 'TRAP', M. Night Shyamalan's Latest Thriller, Struggles With Balancing Suspense and Believability.

M. Night Shyamalan's latest suspense thriller, "Trap," revolves around the intricate dynamics of a father-daughter relationship set against a perilous backdrop. The film stars Josh Hartnett as a father navigating the complex role of a loving parent whilst hiding a dark secret and Ariel Donoghue as his unsuspecting teenage daughter, Ashlyn, who is thrilled to be attending a concert featuring her favorite pop singer.


Key Takeaways

  • Complex Character Dynamics: The film masterfully interweaves the emotional connection between a father and his daughter into its suspenseful narrative.

  • Music as a Central Element: Shyamalan's utilization of his daughter's music career as an integral part of the movie adds a unique layer to the traditional suspense thriller framework.

  • Challenges in Believability: Despite its strong moments, the film struggles with believability in certain plot points, which might detract from the overall experience for some viewers.


Shyamalan effectively captures the nuanced relationship between Hartnett and Donoghue, making the audience empathize with the characters' bonding moments. You fall in love with his daughter so much that you don't want Hartnett to go down because you don't want his daughter to feel bad in any way. This emotional connection forms the bedrock of the film's suspense, compelling viewers to invest deeply in the narrative.


This father-daughter dynamic provides significant depth, adding an emotional layer that is both engaging and thought-provoking. It serves as a reminder that Shyamalan's strength lies not just in creating suspense but also in portraying human emotions in their most vulnerable forms.


Music at the Forefront: A Unique Cinematic Experiment

One of the standout features of "Trap" is the incorporation of Shyamalan's daughter, Saleka's, music career. Her original music and performances play a central role in the film, transforming it into a hybrid between a conventional suspense thriller and a concert movie. This blending of genres offers a fresh take on traditional cinematic storytelling.


But for a good portion of this movie… it just comes of as a commercial for his daughter's music career. This movie plays as a very well produced concert movie. This approach not only showcases Saleka's musical talents but also immerses viewers in a vibrant, audio-visual experience that adds layers of texture to the film.


However, this blending does come with its challenges. The frequent segues into concert scenes, complete with elaborate set designs and multiple outfit changes, can occasionally disrupt the film's pacing. While providing a unique experience, this can detract from the suspenseful atmosphere, leading to a mixed reception amongst viewers.


Balancing Suspense and Believability: A Tightrope Walk

While "Trap" is undeniably engaging, it encounters issues with plot believability that might leave some audiences unconvinced. At its core, the narrative relies on the protagonist, played by Josh Hartnett, strategically navigating a trap set by authorities to capture him. Despite this thrilling premise, certain elements strain credibility.


Everybody that he attempts to get a little bit of information out of… just volunteers the information. The ease with which Hartnett's character obtains critical information from individuals who should be more guarded diminishes the film's tension and challenges audience suspension of disbelief.


Moreover, some plot twists, while surprising, lack coherence when considering the broader context of the characters' motivations, actions and those involved. This underscores the difficulty in maintaining a seamless blend of suspense and realism, which is often a hallmark of Shyamalan's storytelling.


Reflecting on the Journey: Layers of Emotion and Intrigue

"Trap" presents a rich tapestry of emotions, music, and suspense, all masterfully intertwined by Shyamalan. The emotional core, driven by the father-daughter relationship, offers a compelling reason for audiences to stay invested in the narrative. Josh Hartnett's portrayal of a conflicted father adds significant depth, making the character's journey both relatable and heart-wrenching.


Saleka's music, serving as both a narrative device and a showcase of talent, enriches the film's atmosphere but also brings challenges to its pacing and coherence. Despite some plot-related issues, "Trap" manages to deliver a captivating experience, thanks to its unique fusion of genres and strong character work.


The film's ability to oscillate between different emotional and narrative tones offers a distinct cinematic experience, albeit with occasional slips in believability. However, It means well, but doesn't end well.


"Trap" ultimately pushes the boundaries of conventional film-making, offering audiences an intriguing mix of heartfelt emotion, musical exploration, and suspenseful thrill. This convergence of talents and themes underscores Shyamalan's continued innovation in the realm of cinematic storytelling.


TRAP is in theaters now. For a more visual review, check out:



Comments


bottom of page